Review of this four slot lithium ion and nickel metal hydride cell charger.
Product links:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Rechargeable-XTAR-batteries-Professional-Batterys-Black/dp/B0BXCF4FRR
https://www.xtar.cc/product/XTAR-VP4L-Plus-Charger-214.html
Product links:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Rechargeable-XTAR-batteries-Professional-Batterys-Black/dp/B0BXCF4FRR
https://www.xtar.cc/product/XTAR-VP4L-Plus-Charger-214.html
Hello Happy! New Year This is the Xtar Dragon Vp4 L plus lithium ion and nickel metal hydride battery charger. Here it is charging two of these Xar oh what are they 21700 Yes, that's right. 5,000 milliamp hours and you can charge them at half an amp or 1 amp or 2 amps. but you can only use 2 amps if you only use the the outer two bays and if you don't have anything in the middle.
Bays I think if I put one of these cells in a middle Bay it will revert back to 1 amp. Yes, it does now I have four cells in the charger, but you can only see the data which is percentage charged and milliamp hours for two bays at a time. If all four are populated, then you tend to get two and three or the other option is channel one and Channel 4. You can only see two sets of information simultaneously and this charger breaks one of my golden rules which is that I want all my battery chargers to show voltage because this one doesn't show voltage.
well, not um in the normal sense anyway and it doesn't actually show current either. I mean you can see the current that you've selected and we know these cells are charging at 1 amp. but when these get up to about 90% of course they hit Vmax and they go from constant voltage into uh, no, from constant current into constant voltage and therefore the current will start to come down. and you don't see that here because this just shows you what current you've selected.
and so I have found myself taking sneaky voltage measurements like this: 3.72 Vols and this one is 4.24 So that one uh, channel 3, which is at 79% is actually at Vmax. So it's um, doing now a constant voltage charge so the current will be coming down and I've also found myself measuring current by counting these flashes. they're approximately 1 second each. So if we wait for a change on here which is there 31, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8.
so that's about 8 seconds per change. Now it's uh, there's a factor of 3.6 between hours of course and seconds. So 8 seconds is, uh, half an amp. So I Now know that this uh cell in channel 3 is charging at half an amp because it's reached the maximum voltage and the current is being tapered back.
So certainly I Do miss the voltage and current uh indicators. but but there kind of our ways around it now. Any button will bring the display from its dim uh mode back to its bright mode. And then there are three buttons here.
This one's labeled current and refresh. This one is display and this one is record and test. And although most of the button functions are in this manual which is supplied with the charger, I found it necessary to produce a cheat sheet to tell me what all the buttons do because they do different things with a single press with a double press, and with a press and hold. Okay, let's take a quick look at the Box uh Humanistic sound reminder and I saw on the front of here it had record there and I thought that it spoke to you and said uh your batteries are charged but it's not that I don't know what humanistic actually means but I think it just means that the sound reminder is neither too now loud nor too quiet. Um test battery voltage and resistance like a multimeter. Yeah, let's do that next because that's really interesting. You can do lithium ion, nickel metal hydride and eliminate the memory effect function of nickel metal hydride batteries. Well, that's really more nickel cadmium isn't it? Now this does actually say that it can charge 1.2 volt nickel metal hydride and nickel cadmium from quadruple A all the way up to D Siiz cells.
and it can do lithium ion cells right from 10 440 right up to 32650 because these bays are actually quite wide and the L version of this uh battery charger. This L here means that the charger has these longer bays and so you get uh over the nonl version of this charger. you get the ability to charge protected 2700 and 21700 cells so these are actually protected uh 21 700s uh this pouch bag is supplied and it's quite useful cuz there are a few accessories. This is the Main's uh power adapter 12vt 3 amps but that doesn't tell you what range of input voltage this thing will take.
It just says 12 volts on it. Well, the clue is this the car cigarette lighter adapter because this could have on it up to 14 1/2 volts or possibly down to 11 volts. So we know that the input on this charger takes a wide range of measurements. Um, but this is the other thing you get.
It's this pair of probes and I'll look at that next. Well actually, let's take a look at the socketry next. Um, let's turn it around this way. So here's the 12vt 3 amp input.
We know it has a wide Uh voltage range now. there are two USBS marked USB 1 and USB 2. Let's put a little light in these. Uh USB 1.
It doesn't light up I Don't believe it's actually a USB output. USB 2 provides USB 5 volts. Um, so you can charge a phone or something like that and in fact, that will even work if I pull out the 12 vs. Okay, not quite UPS mode.
So let's bring these cells away. I might have to bring them all away, right? And so now it will use the cells in the charger as a source of power and it's running in sort of power bank mode. USB symbol is there. So the USB is providing power.
Let's have a look at that. Yep, that's 5 Vols USB on there. Let's just try this socket again. No, there's no 5 o on here and that's because this socket is used in conjunction with the probes.
Let's have a look at that. So to get into battery testing mode using these probes, you touch them together and it goes into this mode where it shows you voltage and milliohms And now it's a case of putting the black Probe on the negative side of your battery. Apply as much pressure as you can so you get a good contact. And now we should see the voltage of this cell 4.07 Vols and the internal resistance 90 milliohms, 4.07 volts and 85 milliohms.
Let's try a bigger cell. So a 21700 cell and we have 3.95 volts, 26 milliohms o My probe is slipping 3.96 volts, 38 milliohms. So the bigger the cell the lower the internal resistance. Typically and of course, this test is not um, limited to lithium ion Nmc. The battery charger is it can't do lithium ion phosphate. it can't do titanate. certainly can't do sodium ion. but I can test the voltage and internal resistance of this sodium ion cell using the tester because all it's telling us is voltage 2.6 volts and internal resistance 68 Mohms 2 2.6 Vols 68 milliohms Nice and consistent.
Let's get another sodium ion cell or an Lfp cell. This is uh, lithium ion phosphate a little AA size one 3.33 volts, 66 milliohms, 3.33 volts, 66 milliohms right let's try this: Uh 33140 sodium ion cell should have a lower internal resistance than the others and it's 3.25 volts, 5 milliohms or even 4 milliohms. Now cost of milliohm reading is only to uh 1 milliohm. So um, that's the resolution you've got.
Perhaps not enough for these big cells? Let's try an even bigger one. Okay, let's try this. Hakari uh 46145 Sodium ion cell and that that is 3.14 Vols 2 milliohms 3.14 Vols 3 milliohms. Now this is where you need the cheat sheet.
So to exit the internal resistance mode, you need to double press uh the display button so that gets you back to charge. I'll put a couple of cells in. Okay, let's look at the refresh and test modes to get into refresh press and hold the uh. left hand button.
It's marked refresh so there it is. Enter refresh. Uh, hold the current refresh button and this does a DC So a discharge and then a charge. So let's put the cells in and watch it do that and the lights go.
Blue When it's discharging, they're green when they're doing nothing and they're red when it's charging. So these two cells are discharging and you get this sort of moving down animation. Um, so yeah, refreshes discharge and charge. Although I Have found if you put nickel metal hydride in here in refresh mode, the first thing it does with those is charge them.
So for nickel metal hydride, it seems to do a charge discharge charge and I'm not entirely sure why because the test mode does charge discharge charge. So let's go into test mode, press and hold test it goes into test mode. Now that does a charge and then a discharge and it measures the par uh the parameters uh, milliamp hours I think it measures and then it does another charge and I think it stores the discharge measurement and the charge measurement so that you can compare them to see whether you're getting losses due to Uh internal resistance or heat or things like that. So back to the cheat sheet to look at the recorded data, we need to do a single press on this third button that Els us examine the recorded data so you can see that Uh recorded data 2 and this is something I did previously was a charge or actually it was a charge of this not very good uh lithium ion cell and it recorded in charge mode 244 milliamps and in discharge mode 242 milliamps. Yes, it has a very low capacity that cell and if you happen to charge and discharge and have recorded data for all four Bays Again, you switch between them using the display button in the middle so I wasn't record uh any data in channels 2 and three. In fact I only had the cell in Channel 4 and to move forwards and backwards through the recorded data, you can use the left button to go back to record number two or back to record number one and again move between channels one and and four or two and three using the display button and use a single press on the record button to move forwards through the recorded data. And you can see that from my cheat sheet here: Exit: The recorded data is a double press on display. Uh, the first press brings the light back on.
So now a double press. Uh, yes. and we're back to uh, the standard uh charge while we're in test mode. You can come out of test mode actually just by pressing and holding test.
And now we're back in the standard charge mode and all four cells will charge. So how have I found this charger for charging lithium ion cells and having no voltage indication? Yeah, it's not really a problem because you know that the voltage is climbing up to about 80% and then at 80% we're at that maximum of 4.25 it is on this charger. Uh, and you know then that the current is falling down and and you can do this counting flashes thing. uh to guesstimate the current.
but the percentage indicator is actually quite good with lithium ion because it's a very simple, uh, predictable charging curve. What about nickel metal Hydride? Okay, nickel metal hydride. One of the things I find when you have a device that takes four cells is that very often when the cells are near flat, one of them will actually be pushed into negative voltage. So let's see what the unit does if we have negative volage and I'll simulate that by putting it in the wrong way round and it simply says error and beeps quite frantically.
Not so humanistic when it's not happy. But you can get this when the cell's the right way round, but just at zero volts or slightly negative, uh, voltage. Now you can shut the Sounder up because there's a sound off function. On and off it is actually double.
press the right hand button and that mutes the sound. Now all the battery chargers I've got um, struggle. Well, some of them very often struggle with a cell that's at zero volts or ever so slightly negative. This one's not too bad.
Um, it will complain and it will make that um indicating buzzing sound. But if you simply disconnect the cell and then reconnect it and then you might get the the error sound Again, you just simply disconnect it and reconnect it a few times and generally that will instigate a charge of a cell that is completely flat. Uh, like most battery chargers, this thing does occasionally make mistakes with Nickel Metal Hydride in that it doesn't take them right up to 1.5 volts and it can slightly undercharge them. Uh, terminating at about 1.4 volts. That's where I Found having a battery tester that shows you voltage is quite handy. you can take the sell out, just check it. And and if it's at 1.4 and it's not fully charged, put it back in for a bit more charging. Uh, the other thing I found with this charger and it is common to all.
uh. Nickel metal Hydride. Chargers If you charge at one amp, then these are quite warm when they finish charging. So what you could do if you happen to be watching the charger is when they get to about 80% just knock the current down to half an amp.
You can actually charge uh, nickel metal hydrides at 2 amps on here if you don't have the center two bays occupied. I Think 2 amps is probably a bit heavy current for um, these uh, 2,000 milliamp or 2 Amp Hour nickel metal hydrides and I did find an undocumented feature. Uh, this is not in the manual. Uh, if you're doing a refresh charge, so this is doing a discharge and then it will do a charge.
Um, it seems to also include a mythical uh first charge. but that might be because that's actually what it does on nickel metal hydride. But double click the left hand button and you can actually switch it between what the charge parameters were and what the discharge parameters now are. And when this has done a discharge and it goes back to charge mode, you can double click to toggle between the discharge uh parameter and the current charge data undocumented feature.
So what's my conclusion on this charger? I Think it probably is quite a good daily charger for nickel metal hydrides. Uh, with that caveat that you just check them when they come out to make sure that they are fully charged. Uh, definitely make sure you create a cheat sheet for this because it's impossible remembering what these three buttons do in their three different single click, double click and hold modes. Nine functions: Al together.
Uh, it's a fully featured charger for Lithium ion. does half an amp, 1 amp and 2 amps. also does this discharge charge charge and also the charge discharge charge which is the test mode. Uh.
It has power bank mode so it can use the cells in the charger to provide a USB output. and if I switch on the external power, the USB output is maintained, but possibly there's a little uh timing Gap in there. And also of course, if I switch off the Uh 12 VTS then it doesn't immediately switch over to using the cells. in USB power mode, you have to disconnect them and reconnect them and then you can use it as a power bank.
But I Think what I might find most useful for me is um, these test probes where you can measure the internal resistance of really any Uh cell. So big thanks to Xtar for sending me this Uh Dragon Vp4 L plus battery charger and internal resistance tester. uh purchase links will be in the description below the video but that that's it for this video. So cheerio!. .
for NiMH batteries state of charge is not indicated by voltage. Voltage above 1.2-1.3 means nothing.
Not offering much for the high price. At least elapsed time and accumulated charge on my USB charger means simple maths. p.s I wish they would auto-cycle through with more than one cell with an auto / man cycle button if needed, drives you crazy.
My car doesn't have a speedometer but that's fine as I can look at the odometer and count the seconds it takes for it to tick over and then calculate how fast I'm going…
I have a XTAR VC8 charger and I have to say I'm not happy with it. I should warn you and everyone using this charger that the internal resistance test is a complete gimmick. The is a 30mOhm difference slot to slot(some might be the close but at least on my charger some slots show double the resistance on the same test cell. Not to mention they all show different values).It can only discharge on 4 out of the 8 slots, discharges only at 330mA and only has a type-C QC input. Also on my charger slot 4 has a higher self discharge than the others so the capacity test will start again if you leave the cell sitting in the charger for a couple of hours. For the price this one is not worth it. Might as well pay extra 10-20$ and get a something else with more functionality
It's strange this should come out right as I am considering an upgrade to my XTAR VC4 after many years of reliable service. It does display current, voltage and capacity during charge and pulse charges the NIMH. Additional outputs would be useful as well as the test and discharge modes.
Thanks for the review.
interesting equipment
No LiFePO4 support, so I stick to Liitolokala. The Lii-S2 does the basics well for only a few bucks
Did you try triple click? ๐ค
I've found my anyloops recover relatively quickly from 0V, and if I leave them for a while they usually bounce back up to 1.0-1.1V. The only time I've been able to measure a negative voltage was while they were still in the device after they ran flat, or within seconds or removal. For example, I just ran a pair flat in my Game Boy Color [sic], and they read 0.54V and 0.86V in my Opus charger about 30 seconds after removing them from said Game Boy. I immediately removed them from the charger before it started charging and waited about 15 seconds before reinserting them, and they were already up to 0.77V and 0.96V.
I've also found they charge much more evenly and take a higher amount of charge if I let them rest for some time after discharging. For example, I've seen them take around 1200mAh and 1400mAh when charged immediately after discharging (can't remember which was at a lower voltage), whereas they both usually take very close to 1500mAh when I leave them for some time after discharging (usually at least a few hours or overnight). Obviously these are well-used cells, I always let my newer anyloops rest, and their charge level hasn't seemed to drop down over time like my older cells which I always used to charge immediately.
Try out the Vapcell S4 Plus charger, really good charger can charge all slots at 3a at the same time
No voltage and no current display? No thanks.
I have the Adeaska SQ4, whilst lacking the discharge capacity function, the display is much better.
It can charge LiFePO4 as well as Li-ion and NiMh. I would recommend it.
The Xtar display is limited and showing only 2 channels is very poor. The button interface seems clumsy.
Compered to Nitecore charger I think Xtar didnt change quality and they are still the best simple and safest charger on market. Still if you regenerating cell all charger will be permanent demage if cell start leaking, even gas from vented cell can push corosion on board realy fast and you think is bad charger ! Best to use dumy cell with wire and add additional holder next to charger for every cell so if cell leake wont demage charger.
Needs to have live voltage and current on each cell really.
Hello Julian.
You could easily check the current by inserting the probes .
Some insulating material between 2 magnets inserted between the negatives.
The littokala chargers that I own say charge discharge 1A, but the charging current is less.
Cheers.
Happy New Year, I think I will stick with my Opus and Miboxer chargers ๐